PhD Thesis
Instituto Superior Técnico(Lisbon Technical University)




Test of QED and Search for New Physics in Multi-Photonic Final States at LEP2

 

Introduction:

" This thesis will lead you through a dedicated study of final states with photons using the DELPHI detector at LEP. The LEP collider (Large Electron Positron collider) was located at the CERN laboratory in Geneva. It started operating in 1989 and stopped in the year 2000. LEP was the largest electron-positron circular accelerator ever built, operating at the at the highest energies achieved in e+e- colliding beams. There were four beam intersection regions at LEP, where the detectors were located. The DELPHI detector - DEtector with Lepton, Photon and Hadron Identification - was one of the four experiments operating on the LEP collider (ALEPH, DELPHI, L3 and OPAL). Presently, the DELPHI Collaboration is constituted by about 550 physicists, from 56 universities and institutes from 22 different countries.


The Large Electron Positron collider (LEP) was built after the discovery of the Z0 and W bosons at the SPS at CERN in 1983. The main motivation for building LEP was the study the weak interaction at the electroweak scale. The objectives of LEP were to measure with precision the Z0 boson production and decay rates as well its mass and width, to study W+W- production and decay and to exploit the available energy range in the search for the Higgs boson. LEP enabled as well to perform many different types of searches, such as searches for new particles, as new quarks and leptons, and to search for anomalies with respect to the predictions of the Standard Model of Electroweak Interactions.


LEP had two distinct operating phases, known as LEP 1 and LEP 2. The LEP 1 phase started in 1989 and its main aim was to produce and study the Z0 boson. For that purpose, centre-of-mass energy around M_Z0 (~ 91 GeV) had to be achieved. At LEP 1, the most accurate measurements of the Z0 production and decay rates, its mass and width were performed, as well as of other Standard Model parameters, such as the number of neutrino species and the electroweak mixing angle. These results represented an improvement in precision by two orders of magnitude with respect to the pre-LEP measurements. The LEP 2 phase, started in 1996, consisted on the operation of LEP at centre-of-mass energies above the W+W- production threshold. The strong motivation for LEP 2 was to produce on-shell W+W- boson pairs, measure the W mass and width and the W+W- production and decay rates. However, searching for the Higgs boson was also a very strong motivation for increasing the energy in the centre-of-mass, since no evidence for the Higgs had been found at LEP 1 energies.


The motivation for the present thesis was to perform measurements of a Standard Model process and to search for evidence of New Physics beyond the Standard Model using final states made exclusively of photons, selected from the LEP 2 data. The different analyses departed from a general classification of events with just photons, denominated in this context as Multi-Photonic events, which were then classified according to their topology.

At Born level, the reaction e+e- -> gamma gamma (gamma) is exclusively described by Quantum ElectroDynamics (QED), and although at higher orders of perturbation theory, it also has contributions from weak boson interchange, these are nevertheless much smaller than the QED terms, that is, even when comparing just 1-loop level contributions, the QED contribution dominates. Therefore, to measure the total and differential production cross-section for gamma gamma (gamma) at LEP is in fact to test the validity of QED at the electroweak scale. Moreover, if any significant deviation from QED is found, it cannot be explained within the Standard Model framework and there will have to be some New Physics process to account for it. This is why the process e+e- -> gamma gamma (gamma) is known as a benchmark in the search for evidence of Compositness (testing the possibility of the exchange of an excited electron in the t-channel), of contact interactions and other types of models not included in the Standard Model of Electroweak Interactions.


There is a variety of New Physics Models predicting final states in which photons are the only visible particles. In the present thesis, Multi-Photonic events are explored in the search for evidence of a fermiophobic Higgs Boson and of anomalous bosonic couplings of the Higgs boson.


The relevant Multi-Photonic signature in the search for a fermiophobic Higgs Boson consists of final states with two visible photons and missing energy. This signature would be an evidence for the decay of the Higgs boson into two photons when produced in association with a Z0 boson decaying invisibly. In the case of the anomalous couplings of the Higgs boson to the gauge bosons, the most relevant signature is the three photon topology, in which the Higgs boson, produced in association with a photon, decays to a photon pair. In the framework of this model, the two photon plus missing energy signature from HZ0 associated production is also possible.


Searching for New Physics beyond the Standard Model implies that the background processes for the signal signatures are very well known. This is another important motivation for the study Standard gamma gamma (gamma) production. The Standard Model processes yielding Multi-Photonic events are the QED e+e- -> gamma gamma (gamma) process and the production of neutrino-anti-neutrino pairs with the emission of Initial State Radiation (ISR) photons. Neutrino pairs can be produced either by the decay of the Z0 boson or by the t-channel exchange of a W boson. If accompanied by the emission of visible ISR photons, neutrino production channel become visible and can be studied. Moreover, they constitute a major source of background in all searches for New Physics in which final states with photons and missing energy are important signatures.


This thesis is organized in eight chapters. The first two chapters are dedicated to the description of the theoretical frameworks on which the data analyses were based. In chapter 1, the QED e+e- -> gamma gamma (gamma) process is described, while in chapter 2 the explored New Physics models are described. In chapter 3, the concepts used in the statistical treatment of the results of the analyses are introduced. The DELPHI detector is described in detail in chapter 4 with a special focus on the performance of electromagnetic calorimeters which are the most important detectors when studying photons. The photon reconstruction and identification studies performed mostly on simulations of e+e- -> gamma gamma (gamma) events in the DELPHI detector are described in chapter 5. In chapter 6, the real data analysed are introduced for the first time and the selection of the Multi-Photonic samples is described. The two last chapters are dedicated to the specific data analyses and to the interpretations of their results. Chapter 7 focuses on the measurement of the differential and total cross-section of the QED process e+e- -> gamma gamma (gamma) as well as on the derivation of 95% confidence limits on possible deviations from QED. Searches for evidence for New Physics Beyond the Standard Model, both in the framework of a Fermiophobic Higgs boson and of anomalous couplings of the Higgs boson to the gauge bosons, are described in chapter 8."

 

 

Some Results:

e+e- -> gamma gamma (gamma) differential cross-section at LEP 2

Conclusions:

"In the present thesis, analyses of the data collected with the DELPHI detector since 1996 and up to the year 2000 were described. The data corresponded to a total integrated luminosity of 656.5 pb-1 and to energies in the centre-of-mass ranging between 161 GeV and 208 GeV. The data were divided into ten data sets, each corresponding to specific centre-of-mass energy values and data taking periods. Whenever justified, the individual sets were averaged or combined in order to allow more powerful tests of the theory.

The data analyses focused on final states in which the only visible particles were photons, named multi-photonic final states. The framework on which the data analyses were based enabled both to study the almost pure QED process e+e- -> gamma gamma (gamma) and to perform searches for New Physics processes yielding multi-photonic signatures.

The Born differential and total cross-section of the process e+e- -> gamma gamma (gamma) were measured and compared to the theory predictions for each analysed data set. The total and differential cross-sections for e+e- -> gamma gamma (gamma) at an average centre-of-mass energy of 195.6 GeV were derived by combining the information from all data sets. The Born cross-section for the full data set, measured within the geometrical acceptance defined by |cos(theta*)| \in [25º,35º] U [43º,88º] was of:

sigma 0 (dat) = 5.660 +- 0.109 (stat) +- 0.029 (syst) pb

while the corresponding Standard Model prediction is of 5.825pb. A fit of the Born differential cross-section distribution corresponding to the full data set with the SM prediction resulted in a X2/dof of 1.86. No significant difference between the analysed data and the SM prediction was found in any of the ten data sets, and it can be stated that QED remains a valid theory at LEP 2 energies. Lower limits on deviations from QED were therefore derived, translating into bounds on typical energy and mass scales associated to various models going beyond the SM. The 95% C.L. lower limits on the parameters of each model considered are listed below:

QED Cutoff parameter:

Lambda - = 309 GeV and Lambda + = 351 GeV,

Contact Interaction Scale:

Lambda'= 757 GeV,

Excited Electron:

Me*= 337 GeV/c^2 (\lambda_\gamma=1),

String Mass Scale:

M_s(\lambda=-1)= 793 GeV/c^2 and M_s(\lambda=+1)= 901 GeV/c^2.

A confrontation between samples made of three photon final states and the QED predictions for the process e+e- -> gamma gamma (gamma) revealed no departure from the theoretical expectations, a good agreement between data and theory being observed for all analysed data sets.

Further searches for New Physics in multi-photon final states were conducted. A possible fermiophobic Higgs boson, h^0, in the framework of two Higgs doublet models, would have a dominant decay to photon pairs for most of the kinematically allowed h^0 masses at LEP 2. The signal searched was assumed to follow from h^0Z^0 associated production, in which the Z^0 boson would decay invisibly, yielding final states with two photons and missing energy. A good agreement between the data and the Standard Model expectations was found for all data sets. A 95% C.L. lower limit on the mass of such a fermiophobic Higgs boson was derived. This lower bound on M_h^0 was of 98 GeV/c^2, while the expected limit amounted to 97 GeV/c^2.

The existence of anomalous couplings of the Higgs boson to the gauge bosons was probed. The signal corresponded to the production of the Higgs boson in association with a photon or in association with an invisibly decaying Z^0 boson, the Higgs boson decaying to a photon pair. The former reaction would lead to three photon final states and the latter to final states with two photons and missing energy. Given the number of anomalous couplings predicted by the model, some constraints on the parameter space had to be imposed in order to extract 95% confidence limits on the different types of couplings. The more stringent bounds correspond to the case where all couplings of the Higgs boson to the gauge bosons were set to have equal strength. For this parameterization, and for a Higgs mass of 80 GeV/c^2, the allowed values for F/\Lambda^2 range, at 95% C.L., between -10 TeV-2 and 0. TeV-2, while for M_H=160 GeV/c^2, the allowed 95%C.L. region for F/\Lambda^2, falls within -40 TeV-2 and 20 TeV-2.

The work reported in this thesis consisted of a quest for a better understanding the elementary reality, based on data collected with the DELPHI detector at LEP during a 4 year period. My main objective was to attain a reliable and systematic confrontation between the data and the standard theory, always keeping a door opened for a possible, and desired, glimpse on New Physics.

Despite all the effort put in the search for that glimpse of something new, the Standard Model of Electroweak Interactions has stubbornly remained the evidence. This, however, should be regarded on the positive side: the phenomenology of the interactions between the elementary particles up to energies of about 200 GeV is presently well known. It can consequently be stated that the years of LEP were, if not pioneer in finding a new problems for physicists to solve, of the utmost importance in the construction of a very reliable framework from which future demands can depart. "